I’ll be the first to admit that I have a major jewelry addiction. If I’m not wearing a stack of rings or a curated ear setup, I feel like my outfit just isn’t complete. A few months ago, my Instagram feed was basically flooded with girls crew jewelry. You know how the algorithm works—once you look at one cute pair of star-shaped huggies, you get served ads for them for the next three weeks. Usually, I ignore these ads, but there was something about the whimsical, feminine aesthetic of this brand that actually stopped my thumb from scrolling.
I finally gave in and placed an order, and I’ve been wearing their pieces religiously ever since. If you’ve been eyeing their collections and wondering if the quality holds up to the aesthetic, I’m here to give you the lowdown on what it’s actually like to wear them daily.
First Impressions: The Unboxing Experience
There is something to be said for packaging. When my first order arrived, it felt like I was opening a gift from a friend. They use these cute, signature pouches that are actually practical for storing your jewelry later on. I immediately noticed how lightweight the earrings were. Sometimes, gold-plated jewelry can feel clunky or cheap, but the pieces I picked out felt delicate and refined.
I started with a set of their signature butterfly studs and a pair of celestial-themed huggies. The detail work is where they really shine. You can tell they put a lot of thought into the designs, which sets them apart from the mass-produced stuff you find at big-box retailers.
How They Hold Up Over Time
One of the biggest questions I get from friends is, “Do they tarnish?” Look, let’s be real about jewelry. If you are wearing gold-plated pieces in the shower, the pool, or spraying perfume directly onto them every morning, they are going to fade eventually. That’s just the nature of jewelry at this price point.
However, I’ve been pretty careful with my girls crew collection. I take them off before I shower, and I don’t wear them to the gym. After three months of consistent wear, they still look exactly like they did the day they arrived. The clasp mechanisms on the huggies are still tight and secure, which is usually the first thing to break on cheaper earrings. There’s no flimsy feeling when you snap them shut.
What Other People Are Saying
I’m not the only one obsessed with these pieces. I started asking around and looking at what others are saying about their purchases. Here is a little roundup of feedback from people who have been wearing them for a while:
- “I bought the constellation hoops and I’ve literally had three strangers ask me where I got them in the last week. They look expensive but didn’t break the bank.” – Sarah J.
- “The shipping was super fast and the earrings are so comfortable I actually forget I’m wearing them. I sleep in my huggies and they don’t poke me at all.” – Maya K.
- “I have really sensitive ears that get irritated with nickel, but I’ve had zero issues with these. They seem to be really high quality for the price.” – Elena T.
- “I love how easy it is to mix and match everything. I’ve built a whole ear stack just using their different collections.” – Chloe R.
Why I Keep Going Back
The thing that keeps me coming back to the girls crew website is the variety. Whether you are into edgy, minimalist, or super dainty, girly styles, there is something there for you. They have these really cool collaborations and seasonal collections that keep things fresh. It’s hard to find a brand that manages to stay trendy without feeling “fast fashion” and disposable.
I also really appreciate that they cater to people who want a “curated” look. You don’t have to be a professional stylist to figure out how to layer these earrings. The website does a great job of showing how items can be stacked together, which makes shopping so much easier. I’ve personally picked up a few of their ear cuffs because I love the look of multiple piercings without having to actually go and get another hole in my ear.
Are They Worth The Investment?
If you are looking for solid 14k gold jewelry that you can wear for a decade, this isn’t that (and the price reflects that). But if you are looking for pieces that elevate your day-to-day style, allow you to experiment with trends, and offer great value for the price, then these are definitely a win. I feel like the price point is the “sweet spot” for someone who wants to upgrade from cheap drugstore jewelry but isn’t ready to drop hundreds of dollars on a single earring.
I’ve bought a few different styles now, and I’ve noticed that the gold plating has a really nice, warm hue to it. It doesn’t look like that bright, “fake” yellow gold that sticks out in a bad way. It mixes well with my other pieces, even the ones that are slightly different shades of gold.
A Few Tips for Maintaining Your Jewelry
Since I’ve learned a thing or two about taking care of my jewelry collection, here are my personal tips for keeping your girls crew items looking fresh:
- Keep them dry: Moisture is the enemy of gold plating. Don’t leave your earrings in the bathroom while you take a steamy shower.
- The “Last On, First Off” Rule: Put your jewelry on after you’ve applied your lotion, perfume, and makeup. Those chemicals can cause plating to wear down faster.
- Storage matters: Don’t just throw them in a pile. I use a small jewelry box or the pouches they came in to prevent them from scratching against each other.
- Clean gently: You don’t need fancy cleaners. A soft, dry microfiber cloth is usually all you need to buff away any fingerprints or oils.
Final Thoughts
After using these pieces for months, I can safely say they have become a staple in my everyday wardrobe. I reach for my girls crew earrings more often than my more expensive, fine-jewelry pieces because they are just so fun and easy to wear. It’s rare that I find a brand that manages to balance aesthetic, price, and quality so well.
If you have been waiting for a sign to treat yourself or maybe grab a gift for a best friend, this is it. It’s hard to go wrong with their selection, and honestly, building out an ear stack is a pretty therapeutic weekend activity. Just be careful—once you start, it’s really addictive!
I’m already planning my next order for some of their new floral-inspired pieces. I love how they always manage to keep things feeling fresh and seasonal. Whether you’re dressing up for a date night or just trying to feel a little more “put together” while working from home, a good piece of jewelry makes all the difference. Hopefully, this helps you decide if they are the right fit for your collection!
